Pokémon GO: Do the same Shiny Pokémon appear shiny for everyone?

Pokémon Go Water Festival event - Lapras, Totodile, Squirtle, other water Pokémon and everything else you need to know

On Wednesday afternoon, players began to report catching shiny Magikarps in the wild. But will these shiny Pokémon look shiny to every player who encounters them? Or are they unique to the individual Pokémon trainer?

At this time, the latter appears to be the case: the same Pokémon can appear shiny for some players and not for others. That’s based on reports from gamers who have had the experience of catching a shiny Pokémon, then comparing that same Pokémon with a friend, and the two noticing that not both Pokémon are shiny.

On The Silph Road subreddit, user OneLastSpock posted two screenshots of the exact same Magikarp, but it’s shiny for one player and not shiny for the other.

It does not appear that this has to do with one player not having the app up to date, as in most of the situations that have been reported, both users were playing the most recent version of Pokémon GO.

It remains to be seen whether this is an intentional choice on Niantic’s part of if it’s a temporary glitch. Some have speculated that Niantic intentionally made shinies individual to each player so as to discourage spoofing.

Keeping the shinies random like this will also make catching them much more of a random encounter, which is what Niantic seems to be going for. After all, the shiny Pokémon don’t appear shiny on the map, so you’re really only going to know that you have a shiny Pokémon on your hands once you actually start battling with it.

The only two shiny Pokemon that are currently available in the game are Magikarp and Gyarados.